The Best Meal Delivery for Picky Eaters

Being a picky eater, or living with one, is challenging. It seems every meal delivery service is trying to go out of the box with their meals, but these usually don’t appeal to a pickier palate. Being familiar with this, we found the best meal delivery for picky eaters that make meal planning a breeze and offer delicious meals that (almost) everyone will love.

HelloFresh is our top choice due to its impressive variety, quality, and affordability. Others services made our list too. Find out where they rank and discover which one is best for you.

HelloFresh

Winner

Where Does HelloFresh Deliver
5/5

HelloFresh is one of the best meal delivery services for picky eaters. One of the reasons they have such an advantage over the competition is their wonderful variety of meals. The weekly menu rotates, and on any given week, you can have as many as more than sixty meal options to choose from.

Even the pickiest eater can find something they enjoy with that type of variety.

HelloFresh is a meal kit delivery service, which means you pick the meal, and they ship pre-measured ingredients, along with easy-to-follow recipes. It’s a little more work than prepared meals, but you also have more control over the cooking process and how the end product tastes.

HelloFresh offers family-friendly meals that are 100% picky eater approved, like glazed pork chops with garlicky green beans, beef tenderloin and gouda sandwiches, shepherd’s pie, and bacon spaghetti.

With HelloFresh, you can choose a meal plan for the whole family by choosing the plan for four people, then choose the number of meals you want per week, from two to six.

Prices start at $8.99 per serving.

Key Benefits:

  • HelloFresh is known for its fresh ingredients and great taste
  • Meals the whole family will love 
  • Great variety of well-liked meals on the weekly menu
  • Meal kits are delivered fresh
  • One of the cheapest meal kit service options you can find

Home Chef

Best Meal Kit

home Chef box 900
4.8/5

Home Chef offers meal kits that are full of wonderful flavors that picky eaters will approve of. Of all the meal kit services, Home Chef offers the most meal kits that appeal to a wide range of tastes and preferences. They were a close contender for the top spot. However, their weekly menu isn’t as large or quite as diverse as the one offered by HelloFresh.

Meal kits offer you the chance to do a little cooking without all the grocery shopping or prep work. Each Home Chef meal kit includes how long the recipe takes, and the skill level required. If you’re a picky eater that wants to improve your culinary skills, Home Chef offers some of the best meal kits. Home Chef also offers a small selection of oven-ready meals.

Home Chef offers categories for healthy meals that include calorie-conscious and carb-conscious, and they indicate whether each meal kit contains a common allergen. Keep in mind if you’re gluten-free, dairy-free, or have a different food intolerance, these meal kits are all prepared in a shared facility.

Samples of picky-eater-friendly Home Chef meal kits include pasta with sausage ragu, shrimp scampi, and mushroom pasta penne.

Home Chef offers a two-person plan, or you can choose a meal plan for four or six people if you’re feeding a family of picky eaters. Then choose how many meals per week, from two to six.

Prices start at $9.99 per serving.

Key Benefits 

  • Offers a filter to choose foods you don’t want in your meal kits
  • Great taste without too many exotic flavors
  • Low-calorie and low-carb meals for a healthier lifestyle
  • Most meal kits can be ready in 30 minutes or less
  • Oven-ready meals also available for busy nights

Nurture Life

Best For Kids

Nurture Life Review
4.8/5

Busy families with picky eaters understand firsthand how frustrating it can be serving meals when one or more of the littles isn’t having anything to do with what’s on their plate. Sometimes, having single-serving meals that are picky-eater and kid-approved is what you need, especially when those meals are also healthy.

Meal delivery services like Nurture Life are a lifesaver for busy parents who want easy meal choices for their picky kids.

Nurture Life offers kids meals, finger foods, smoothies, and snacks. With reasonable portions, you don’t have to worry about food waste or your little one going hungry. Nurture Life is suitable for both toddlers and bigger kids.

Some of the best kid-friendly recipes on the menu include chicken taco pockets with hidden veggies and brown rice, whole grain french toast sticks with scrambled eggs, and mac & cheese with hidden butternut squash. Their category of finger foods are versions of their meals that are cut into finger food-sized chunks for older babies and toddlers.

Nurture life helps you save time and makes meal planning easier. Choose from six, nine, twelve, or fifteen meal choices per week. Prices start at $6.99 per meal or item.

Key Benefits 

  • Meals labeled specifically for picky eaters
  • More than two dozen kid-friendly recipes per week 
  • Choose your own meal plan and meals 
  • Dietary preference filters like gluten-free, egg-free, and milk-free 
  • Hidden vegetables for a nutritional boost

Meal Kits for Picky Eaters

Blue Apron

Blue Apron Meal Delivery
4.8/5

Blue Apron is arguably one of the most popular meal kit delivery services, and with good reason. Not only were they one of the originals, but they also offered meal kit options that are packed with the types of flavors that most people love.

Blue Apron offers about twelve meal kit options each week, including their wellness meal kits, which are Weight Watchers-approved. They also have a family meal plan called Signature for Four, with well-liked favorites like chicken enchiladas, oven-baked cornbread chili casserole, and lemon caper pork.

Choose to have meals for two or the family plan for four. Choose to have two meals, three meals, or four meals delivered per week. Prices start at $9.99 per serving.

Key Benefits

  • About a dozen meal kits per week, plus a couple of prepared meal options
  • Family meal plan available
  • Well-liked flavors and traditional favorites
  • Meal kits for your healthy lifestyle
  • Affordable

Marley Spoon

Martha Marley Spoon
4.8/5

Marley Spoon has the best meal kits for people who are picky about the quality of ingredients. Marley Spoon creates fresh meals using seasonal produce that are delivered to your door in the form of easy-to-make kits.

A few examples of Marley Spoon, meal delivery kits include Greek pan-roasted salmon, chicken with mushroom sauce, and baked fish with oven chips.

What’s even better is that all of Marley Spoon’s meal kits are prepared in six simple steps or less. Choose meals for two or family meal kits for four. Then choose between two and six meal kits to have delivered each week.

Prices start at $8.69 per serving.

Key Benefits

  • One of the most well-respected meal kit services 
  • More than four dozen meal kits each week
  • Some breakfast options in the meal selection 
  • Easy to prepare 
  • Family-friendly meal plans 

Prepared Meals for Picky Eaters

Factor Meals

factor meals review f

Factor Meals are fresh, designed by dietitians, and delicious because there’s a culinary team involved in the process. Factor focuses on healthy meals, but they know that sometimes convenient health foods lack taste and texture, making them a no-go for picky eaters.

Factor Meals arrive fresh, ready to heat and eat, with food that tastes great without going overboard on spices or introducing flavors that are too exotic. That’s not to say their meals are bland or boring, because they’re not. Factor also uses organic ingredients when possible, so you know the quality is there for picky and discerning appetites.

Factor offers more than thirty meals each week, with keto, calorie-smart, and vegetarian options. Meals start at about $10.99 per serving.

Key Benefits

  • Good variety of traditional American favorites mixed in with international cuisines
  • Side dishes are simple, like garlic green beans and roasted squash
  • A great option for picky keto eaters
  • Cold-pressed juices, smoothies, and snacks are available.

MealPro

Mealpro Box

MealPro is a prepared meal delivery service offering tasty food that doesn’t go overboard on seasoning and spices. If you’re put off by the number of spices others put into their food in an attempt to make it taste good, then MealPro is a great option for you. They rely on the quality of their food and recipes to provide great flavor.

We also like MealPro because they’re one of the few meal delivery services for picky eaters that offers a decent selection of vegetarian meals. Keep in mind these meals aren’t entirely plant-based, but they do fit into a vegetarian lifestyle. We like other vegetarian services, like Purple Carrot, but the dishes and flavors on the menu aren’t always well-received by picky eaters.

You don’t need a subscription with MealPro, but there is a minimum order of twenty meals. One meal starts at about $!0 per serving.

Key Benefits

  • No subscription needed
  • Large menu of more than thirty meals 
  • Meals are customizable
  • Delivered fresh, not frozen
  • Meals are not overly seasoned

What To Look For

logo leaf new

Large Meal Options

One of the most important factors when looking for a meal delivery service for picky eaters is a large menu. Some only offer about six meals a week, and if you don’t already know you’re going like most meals they offer, this often isn’t enough for a pickier eater.

A menu with good variety will usually include at least a dozen meals to choose from, like our winner, HelloFresh, which offers nearly sixty choices each week.

Ability to Choose Your Own Meals

Not being able to choose your own meals can be a waste of money if you’re a picky eater. Some offer a chef-curated menu that they ship out weekly, and you don’t get any say in what arrives. While this food may be delicious, it may also not be what you want. Instead, make sure the service you choose allows you to choose. If they allow customization, then that’s even better.

Filters for Foods and Allergies

If you have any dietary restrictions, allergies, or food preferences, make sure the meal delivery service you choose can accommodate your needs. Look for filters that make it easier to find meals that don’t contain the ingredients you want to avoid. Another option is to look for a service that doesn’t include those ingredients at all.

For example, if you’re dairy-free, a plant-based meal delivery service will leave you with no worries.

Common Recipes for a Wide Audience

Finally, for picky eaters, a menu that offers recipes with wide appeal is important. This indicates that the meal delivery service understands how to please palates that don’t like a lot of spice, exotic flavors, unfamiliar dishes, and unappealing textures.

Often meal kit options are the better choice for this, and the best meal kit services offer a menu with great variety, such as HelloFresh and Marley Spoon.

FAQs

logo leaf new

HelloFresh has some of the best meal kits for picky eaters, along with a large menu with lots of variety and choices every week. 

Nurture Life is a great choice for kid-friendly meals for both toddlers and big kids. They understand that kids can be picky eaters, and they also add vegetables in unsuspecting ways to each dish. 

EveryPlate is a budget meal delivery option that can be good for picky eaters. Some reviews state the food is a little on the bland side, but this isn't necessarily a bad thing for everyone. 

Bottom Line

logo leaf new

HelloFresh wins as our overall top pick for the best meal delivery for picky eaters. Their variety and quality are top-notch. Home Chef and Nurture Life round out the top three, but there are several other great meal services for pickier eaters. Give them a try and see for yourself.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top

Meal Delivery Services Comparison Download

meal delivery services comparison

We compare meal delivery services for price, shipping, number of meal options, and organic ingredients. Get your free download now.

100% Secure. We never share your email! Your privacy is protected.